UK report lists 4 Indian Rafales as inactive; ex-Air Chief calls claim ‘false’
Amid Pakistan’s claims of shooting down Indian fighter jets during air-to-air combat following India’s air strikes in response to the Pahalgam attack, a UK-based aviation publication has noted in its 2027 World Air Forces directory that 32 of India’s 36 Rafale fighter jets are active, while the number of Pakistan’s Saab 2000 Erieye airborne early warning aircraft has also fallen from nine to seven, although an aircraft being classified as inactive does not necessarily mean that it was lost in combat.
The directory, released by British publication FlightGlobal, marks a change from its previous edition, published in November 2025, which had listed 35 Rafales in India’s operational fleet. The latest assessment also comes amid continuing uncertainty over aircraft losses during the four-day military confrontation between India and Pakistan in May 2025.
India’s Ministry of Defence has not commented on the figures, although The Hindu, quoting unidentified ministry officials, reported that they had questioned the authenticity of the data and said the ministry had not supplied the information.
FlightGlobal relied on open-source fleet-tracking data compiled by British aviation intelligence firm Cirium, yet its latest report does not explain why the figures have changed over the past twelve months.
Cirium monitors military fleets using tail numbers and public sightings, so aircraft undergoing prolonged depot-level overhauls or structural upgrades are routinely omitted from active rosters without necessarily indicating combat attrition.
The directory displays glaring numerical inconsistencies, for it credits the Indian Air Force with 263 active Su-30MKIs despite the service operating a maximum fleet of 260 jets. Retired Air Marshal Narmdeshwar Tiwari, who served as Vice Chief of the Air Staff during the conflict, dismissed the publication's findings as patently false on social media, and he urged the editors to scrutinise their informants.
He pointed out that the listed tail numbers have subsequently participated in international aerial exercises, while the same unverified sources had previously fabricated rumours regarding the capture of Squadron Leader Shivangi Singh.
The contested figures stem from the four-day border escalation in May 2025, when India launched Operation Sindoor against terrorist camps in Pakistan and Pakistan-occupied Kashmir following the Pahalgam terror attack that claimed 26 lives.
While a ceasefire was brokered on May 10, both nations have since traded unverified claims regarding aerial losses, and New Delhi has formally acknowledged losing an undisclosed number of aircraft during the initial hostilities.
Defence Secretary RK Singh explicitly refuted assertions that multiple Rafales were downed, whereas French Air Force chief General Jérôme Bellanger suggested evidence pointed toward the loss of a single Rafale, a Mirage 2000, and a Su-30MKI.
Then-Indian Air Force chief Amar Preet Singh asserted that Indian forces destroyed five Pakistani F-16 and JF-17 fighters alongside a large airborne early warning aircraft, and Islamabad has acknowledged strikes on its airbases whilst remaining silent on fleet losses.