Dowry harassment a collective shame to society: Delhi High Court

New Delhi: The Delhi High Court has described dowry harassment that drives married women to suicide as a collective shame, while acquitting a woman's father-in-law and brother-in-law and converting her husband's dowry-death conviction into one for abetment of suicide, according to reports.

Justice Vimal Kumar Yadav delivered the ruling in appeals filed by Jai Dev, his father Chhotey Lal and brother Veeru against their trial court convictions. Sonia died after setting herself on fire at her matrimonial home in Vijay Vihar, Delhi, on October 17, 2001.

The prosecution alleged that Sonia was harassed over demands for a motorcycle, a gas stove, a water motor, and Rs 25,000. Her parents told the court that she had stayed at their home for months because of marital discord. Jai Dev later brought her back, assuring them he would treat her well. She died about one-and-a-half months after returning.

The High Court found that the prosecution had not established dowry-linked cruelty soon before her death. It said the allegations against Chhotey Lal and Veeru were vague and did not identify specific acts by either man. Both were acquitted of all charges.

The court, however, held Jai Dev responsible for cruelty, citing the persistent marital discord and his breach of the assurance given to Sonia's family. It maintained his conviction under Section 498A of the Indian Penal Code and converted his conviction under Section 304B for dowry death to Section 306 for abetment of suicide.

His sentence under Section 498A was retained, while the sentence under Section 306 was limited to the period of imprisonment already undergone.

Tags: