Plea to UN flags risks of ‘backdoor NRC’, Muslims’ exclusion from citizenship through Census 2027
A petition to the UN by the South Asia Justice Campaign (SAJC) over India's proposed Census 2027 has raised concerns that the exercise, particularly its notified questionnaire, could pave the way for the exclusion of Muslims and other minority communities from citizenship, while potentially deepening communal hostility by increasingly portraying minorities as demographic threats rather than equal rights-holders.
In its November 14 submission to the UN Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR), the civil society platform warned that the combination of the census, a newly constituted government committee on demographic changes and existing citizenship-related exercises could facilitate the establishment of a nationwide National Register of Citizens (NRC).
India is conducting its first national census since 2011, and SAJC noted that the questionnaire, notified on August 14, 2026, seeks information including identity document numbers, parents’ names, religion and places of birth, alongside mobile numbers, voter ID and Aadhaar details.
Eight of its 40 questions, the organisation pointed out, correspond to those in the 2020 National Population Register (NPR) schedule, which the Ministry of Home Affairs had previously described as the first step towards an NRC.
The submission also questioned the mandate of a High-Level Committee on Demographic Changes, constituted by the Home Ministry on May 26 and chaired by a retired Supreme Court judge, which is tasked with examining population changes attributed to illegal immigration and other abnormal reasons, as well as studying demographic shifts among religious and social communities.
SAJC argued that the committee’s framing presupposes illegal immigration as a cause of demographic change before any investigation has been conducted, while its invitation to private individuals to submit information could expose communities to unverified or politically motivated allegations.
The organisation further raised concerns over an October 16 amendment to the Census Rules, 1990, which allows private individuals to be appointed as census enumerators, warning that inadequate safeguards could compromise the impartiality of the exercise and disproportionately affect minorities.
Drawing parallels with Assam’s NRC, whose final list excluded approximately 1.9 million people in August 2019, SAJC noted that the register remains formally unnotified, while those excluded have yet to receive the rejection slips necessary to challenge their exclusion before Foreigners Tribunals.
The submission also placed these developments alongside the nationwide Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls, warning that their cumulative impact could threaten equality, privacy, dignity and security, and expose Muslims and other minorities to discrimination and statelessness.