Neutrality in the face of genocide is complicity: Rahul Gandhi draws flak over Israel ties
The senior Congress leader and Leader of the Opposition, Rahul Gandhi’s views on a strong relationship with Israel, including weapons trade deals, drew wrath from rights group members, pointing to the growing number of countries that call out Israel’s treatment of Palestine as genocide, and who argue that, when nations are severing ties with Israel, calling for strong ties with that country is akin to normalising the genocide.
Rahul delivered these remarks on Wednesday during an interaction with Professor Pape at the University of Chicago, and he later elaborated upon his stance via the social media platform X, asserting that India’s foreign policy must be guided strictly by national interest, yet he maintained that acquiring superior weaponry from Israel does not necessitate silence regarding the plight of Gaza.
He explicitly condemned the October 7th attacks alongside Israel’s subsequent actions in the strip, but he stopped short of employing the term genocide to describe the ongoing devastation. Furthermore, he declared that a nation of 1.5 billion souls ought not to be constrained by any foreign power, and he insisted that India must confidently occupy its rightful position upon the global stage.
“I condemn the October 7th attacks and the killing of innocent people. I also condemn what Israel has done in Gaza. One wrong cannot justify another,” Gandhi wrote, arguing that no country, including Israel, the United States, Russia or China, should constrain India from playing its rightful role on the international stage.
However, this attempt at diplomatic equilibrium failed to pacify progressive commentators, and it instead ignited backlash across digital forums, with Delhi University professor Apoorvanand expressing profound disappointment at the endorsement of amicable ties with an apartheid regime, and he contended that one cannot credibly combat genocidal politics domestically while embracing them abroad.
Similarly, senior journalist Arfa Khanum Sherwani lamented that Rahul Gandhi had squandered a pivotal international platform, for he spoke readily of October 7th yet remained conspicuously mute on the subsequent Palestinian agony.
Commentator Deepa Khader argued that strategic diplomacy ought never to supersede fundamental human principles, and she noted that liberal politicians frequently compromise their stated ideals whenever geopolitical interests intervene.
Meanwhile, activist Prashant linked Israeli defence imports directly to domestic repression in Kashmir, and he questioned how Rahul Gandhi could champion a politics of love while endorsing commerce with an aggressor state.
An X user, Arshiya, who described themselves as an admirer of Rahul Gandhi, said political support did not mean abandoning personal principles, adding that neutrality in the face of genocide amounted to complicity.
Journalist Shams Tabrez Qasmi observed that Sonia Gandhi had repeatedly critiqued India’s burgeoning closeness to Israel in her published essays, whereas her son was now actively legitimising the ruling party’s foreign policy trajectory. Qasmi also observed that history did not begin on 7 October, criticising Gandhi for appearing to defend a policy pursued by the Modi government.
Muhammad Faraz Ahmed, Telangana state president of the Students Islamic Organisation, echoed these sentiments, and he warned that such rhetoric merely emboldens regional Congress governments to welcome Israeli defence firms into Indian states.
Commentators like Rakesh Kumar recalled that the Congress party itself had established full diplomatic relations with Israel in 1992, and they concluded that Rahul Gandhi’s reluctance to utter the word genocide was an unsurprising continuation of historical precedent.