AFP via Getty Images photo.

‘Questions are tough’: facing journos, Trump tells deadpan-faced Modi

New Delhi: US President Donald Trump told Prime Minister Narendra Modi that facing questions from journalists was “very tough” during an impromptu press interaction at the Quad summit in Manila, a remark that Modi's critics interpreted as a sarcastic reference to the Indian Prime Minister's absence from unscripted press conferences during his 12 years in office.

The exchange, captured on video, took place on November 17, as Modi stood alongside Trump, Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese and Japanese Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi. When journalists began directing questions at Trump, Modi appeared to gesture towards the meeting venue and asked, “Shall we move?”

The other leaders remained in place as Trump continued taking questions for around three minutes. Journalists raised issues including Nvidia, a Deutsche Bank leak, his planned meeting with Chinese President Xi Jinping and Iran.

At one point, Trump turned towards Modi and Takaichi and remarked, “See, I get these questions? Very tough.” Asked about the Quad, he described the three other leaders as “phenomenal people” and called Modi “a very tough man”. Modi maintained a largely expressionless face, while Trump added that Takaichi “may be even tougher”.

The footage of the interaction circulated widely, drawing attention to Modi’s response to an unscripted exchange with the press.

The episode came days after Modi addressed journalists at the BJP headquarters during the Diwali Milan event on November 12. He claimed that he has a longstanding association with the media and claimed, “I believe in communication.” He also spoke about journalists who had attended his swearing-in as Gujarat chief minister in 2001.

However, in his 12 years as Prime Minister since 2014, Modi has not held a solo, unscripted press conference in India. He has only rarely taken questions from journalists during overseas visits.

In May, during his visit to Norway, Modi walked away without responding when Norwegian journalist Helle Lyng asked why he did not take questions from the press. The question was put to him as he was leaving a joint press statement with Norwegian Prime Minister Jonas Gahr Støre, which had no question-and-answer session.

Lyng asked: “Prime Minister Modi, why don't you take some questions from the freest press in the world?” Neither leader stopped to respond.

The Indian embassy subsequently invited her to a briefing later that evening, where she asked why Norway should trust India, whether the government could promise to stop human rights violations, and whether Modi would begin taking critical questions from the Indian press.

External Affairs Ministry Secretary (West) Sibi George responded at length, speaking about India's civilisational history, but did not directly address the questions. When Lyng pointed this out, he asked her not to interrupt.

Tags: