Even as she was being hunted down by a mob of Hindutva communal men during the 2002 Gujarat massacre, a simple woman named Bilkis Banu must have believed that the great constitution and judiciary of this country would be on her side, and that all the people of this country would stand by her. The decision of the state government, the main sponsors of the genocide, was to carefully cover up the assailants who gang-raped the five-months pregnant Bilkis Banu, and killed 14 of her family members, including her three-year-old daughter. But Bilkis did not falter; determined that she would not bow down to any power except the Lord, she walked up the huge steps of the court, holding the hand of her life partner Yakub Rasool.

Tere were attempts to sabotage the case right from the beginning. In 2004, the Supreme Court transferred the trial to Maharashtra due to concerns whether a fair trial would be possible in the state of Gujarat, the area of influence of the accused. In January 2008, a special CBI court found 11 accused guilty and sentenced them to life imprisonment; the Bombay High Court upheld this sentence in May 2017, rejecting the appeal of the accused. Although every humanitarian said consolilngly that it was a historic verdict and justice had been served, that was not to be. For the ruling establishment was on the prowl for the next opportunity.

In 2022, the year the country celebrated its 75th anniversary of independence, the Gujarat government granted good certificates to the entire lot of these accused and released them. The Sangh Parivar leadership, including ministers, honored these gangs of rapists and murderers with garlands. Even though Bilkis was exhausted by the torture, threats and struggles, she did not bow her head and approached the Supreme Court. Rights activists like Subhashini Ali, Revati Laul, Roop Rekha Verma, Mahua Moitra and organizations like the National Federation of Indian Women and Citizens for Justice and Peace joined the case through public interest litigation. The bench of Justice B.V. Nagaratna and Justice Ujjwal Bhuyan, which considered the case, quashed the Gujarat government's order on January 8, 2024 and sent the accused back to jail. We were once again consoled that the Supreme Court is there as recourse to those who have no one.

Now, in a mockery of all the solace and struggles, the Supreme Court has granted bail to two of the accused in the case by freezing their sentences. The apex court granted this relief on the grounds that they have served more than 17 years in prison, one of the accused is physically disabled and there are legal issues that need to be resolved in the appeal. However, the judges forgot that the Supreme Court itself had dismissed the special leave petitions filed by the accused against the life sentence in 2017. Moreover, while considering this bail plea, it was not even ready to hear the side of the survivor. When we examine the unparalleled cruelty of the crime and the procedures of the case, it is clear that this decision will only help to subvert the justice system.

The claim that the accused have spent more than 17 years in jail is also a blatant lie. Even according to the figures submitted by the Gujarat government to the Supreme Court in 2022, both the accused who were granted bail had been out of jail for about three years on parole and other means. In addition, they had been free for about 17 months following the illegal commutation of their sentences by the Gujarat government in August 2022. It is without taking into account all these long periods spent outside the jail that the consideration of ‘long-term imprisonment’ has been given. It is true that convicts have a constitutional right to appeal and to seek commutation on health grounds. But, shouldn’t the safety and rights of the victim be considered while granting such commutations in heinous crimes like mass murder and gang rape?

It would not be surprising if the remaining accused, on the trail of this bail order, seek similar relief and are granted it. The anti-Muslim genocide in Gujarat and the sexual violence during that were a declaration that the minority community, especially its women, have only limited rights and powers in this country. Even after years, the communal fascists who are steering the government have been telling Bilkis Banu and her community that no matter how much they fight against discrimination and violence holding up the law and the constitution they will be chopped down. And if the judiciary also stand with those predators, then what is the meaning the word 'justice' ?


Tags: