Let there be clear caste-wise data in the census
When it comes to the 2027 Census, It feels as though the authorities involved are demonstrating extraordinary knack of complicating the conduct of the exercise. The frequent decisions rolled out by the government and census officials, followed by their abrupt withdrawals, point directly to this. The pity is that such illogical decisions are occurring in a massive nationwide exercise that is to take place only once every ten years—though this time, the gap will be 16 years. Among the 13 additional questions included in the demographic questionnaire of the 2027 Census compared to 2011, under the heading of "Religion" — alongside the six major religions of Hindu, Islam, Christian, Sikh, Buddhist, and Jain — authorities initially provided a drop-down menu under the "Others" category to select one from a list of 287 religions, only to withdraw it within a single day following massive uproar and queries by newspapers. According to the list released by census officials, movements, institutions, and sub-sects such as the Sri Krishna Movement, Ramakrishna Paramahamsa, Sanatana, Sri Ram, Valmiki, Ramdev, Bishnoi, Sarna, Tantric, Yogi, Shia, Sunni, Pentecostal, and Methodist would all have had to be recorded as distinct religions.
Also read: Census 2027: religions including ISKCON get listed under ‘Others’
The backdrop reported to have led to this is a demand by tribal communities, who maintain distinct worship practices, to preserve their unique religious identity accordingly and not be clubbed under the broad general category of Hindus. The 'Sarna' community is a prime example. In the 2011 Census, their population came to 4.5 million, accounting for 62 percent of the total 8 million listed under the "Other Persuasions" category. Community members pointed out that their numbers were even higher than the national population of Jains, who were counted as a main religious category. While religion was a question item in the 2011 Census as well, alongside the six mentioned religions, there was a category for "Other Religions and Persuasions," complete with a column to write it in. However, this category accounted for just 0.7 percent of the population, while those who did not state a religion made up only 0.2 percent.
Also read: Manipur High Court puts Census 2027 on hold until April 30
As a matter of fact, a pre-determined list with a drop-down menu is necessary for more than religion, for the caste section. In the upcoming census — which is being conducted digitally and incorporating caste data for the first time in history — drop-down options have currently been provided only for Scheduled Castes (SCs) and Scheduled Tribes (STs) as designated caste categories. Apart from those, everyone else must record their caste by typing it into an open text field anew, as a caste name they choose to write. There is as yet no indication that the government has any clear guidelines on how to categorise and tabulate castes out of such data coming from 150 crore people. This is also the first time self-enumeration is taking place. Consequently, matters do not appear as though the creators of this system first asked themselves the critical question of how caste would actually be entered in this open box. To understand the social, educational, and economic progress of caste groups and to distribute state resources in a way that aids their advancement — while also ascertaining the count of religious adherents — such statistical data is essential. Yet, with caste classification set to be filled out in an open column in a manner that renders proper categorisation nearly impossible, individuals are likely to jot down caste names in whatever spelling or language they personally understand. It is precisely because of this glaring flaw that Other Backward Classes (OBCs) and opposition parties are strongly demanding that it be rectified.
Also read: OBC labour: India’s uncounted economic powerhouse
It is unfortunate that this has to be pointed out after the 2027 Census procedures have already progressed quite far. Following the first phase of house listing, just three days ago (November 16), the portal for self-enumeration — the second phase of the census — was opened in the states of Uttar Pradesh, Uttarakhand, Goa, and Punjab, where elections are due in 2027. The experience of the 2011 Census itself stands as proof of what it would look like when caste names are typed freely into the current form. Back then, when examining the total count of self-written caste names that were not selected from a drop-down list, there were a staggering 4.6 million caste names across India! Does the government really want yet another set of chaotic figures like this? Is the government deciding that no single caste should ever be measurable using precise social, educational, and economic data? If that is not the intention, the urgent course of action is to rectify this in a manner satisfying at least common sense. The justification offered by government circles for not providing a drop-down list of caste names was that they do not possess a comprehensive master list of all castes in the country. If such a list does not exist, shouldn't compiling it be made a basic part of this entire exercise? One cannot entirely blame those who suspect that a cunning logic is at play here — hoping that another 50 lakh fragmented caste names will emerge, under the pretext of which backward classes ultimately will fail to qualify for any benefits.