Begin typing your search above and press return to search.
proflie-avatar
Login
exit_to_app
exit_to_app

Kerala HC flags PIL angle in challenge to clean chit for CM Satheesan in Punarjani case

text_fields
bookmark_border
The Kerala High Court on Monday indicated that a fresh challenge to the closure of a Vigilance inquiry involving Chief Minister V.D. Satheesan and Manappat Foundation chairman Ameer Ahamed may need to be treated as a public interest litigation rather than an ordinary writ petition
Kerala HC flags PIL angle in challenge to clean chit for CM Satheesan in Punarjani case
cancel

Kochi: The Kerala High Court on Monday indicated that a fresh challenge to the closure of a Vigilance inquiry involving Chief Minister V.D. Satheesan and Manappat Foundation chairman Ameer Ahamed may need to be treated as a public interest litigation rather than an ordinary writ petition.

Justice C. Jayachandran made the observation while hearing a petition filed by a self-described whistleblower who has sought to contest the clean chit given in the Punarjani-FCRA matter. The judge said the plea appeared to raise issues of public interest and directed the court registry to place it before the Chief Justice for allocation to an appropriate Bench.

The court also indicated that the petitioner’s legal standing would have to be examined along with the substantive allegations. “There is a strong prima facie indication that the writ petition, if at all liable to be considered on merits, partakes the character of a public interest litigation,” the judge observed.

The petition relates to allegations that Satheesan sought foreign contributions for the Punarjani flood rehabilitation project during a private visit to the United Kingdom in October 2018. The petitioner claims that £22,500 raised for the initiative was channelled through the Manappat Foundation in breach of the Foreign Contribution (Regulation) Act, 2010.

According to the plea, the then Vigilance and Anti-Corruption Bureau director had favoured a CBI investigation after identifying suspicious transactions amounting to more than Rs 1.22 crore across Ameer Ahamed’s FCRA, current and personal bank accounts. The petitioner alleges that the preliminary inquiry was subsequently shut down after authorities concluded that no vigilance angle existed.

The petition also questions the timing of the decision to drop corruption allegations against Satheesan, claiming it came soon after the declaration of the 2026 Assembly election results. The petitioner maintains that he is entitled to challenge the closure both as a whistleblower and as a concerned citizen.

The state, however, contested the maintainability of the petition. Advocate General K. Jaju Babu argued that the petitioner had no direct connection with the original complaint and therefore could not seek judicial review of the Vigilance decision.

He further told the court that Jason Panikulangara, one of the original complainants, had withdrawn an earlier writ petition in 2020 before filing a public interest litigation seeking a CBI probe. That petition was dismissed by a Division Bench, which refused to direct a CBI investigation and advised the complainant to explore other legal remedies.

The Advocate General also submitted that neither of the original complainants had continued pursuing the matter and that the Vigilance proceedings had attained finality.

The High Court has not yet gone into the merits of the allegations against Satheesan or the propriety of the decision to close the inquiry. The immediate question before the court is procedural: whether the Chief Justice should assign the matter to a PIL Bench and whether the petitioner has the right to maintain the challenge.

(Inputs from IANS)

Show Full Article
Next Story