Supreme Court proposes fines for states over rising Yamuna pollution
The Supreme Court has proposed penalising states and Union territories if the quality of Yamuna water deteriorates within their jurisdictions, holding local administrations accountable for pollution in the river.
Expressing concern over the river's worsening condition, the court said that despite huge sums being spent on cleaning it, pollution levels had continued to rise. It said the condition of the Yamuna and its 520 drains reflected "everything that is wrong with civic administration" in towns, cities and villages along its banks.
In its November 4 order, the court pointed to contradictions in the Yamuna Action Plan. While the plan claimed that water bodies and wetlands in Delhi's O-Zone were free of encroachments, an annexure listed all 35 water bodies and wetlands in the area as encroached.
The court called for protecting the O-Zone as a green zone and extending it upstream and downstream, if feasible, from the Yamuna's source to its confluence with the Ganga. It said no permanent structures, except green parks and essential public infrastructure, should be allowed in the zone.
The court also noted that none of Delhi's 37 sewage treatment plants (STPs) met the standards prescribed by the Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB). Only five complied with the prescribed bacteriological limits.
Observing that the Yamuna was "one continuous ecosystem", the court said states and Union territories must share responsibility for protecting it. Their individual obligations should depend on their contribution to pollution and their capacity to address it.
The CPCB has been directed to formulate a compensation formula for deteriorating water quality. States can recover penalties from polluters and officials found negligent.
The court also ordered all STPs, Common Effluent Treatment Plants and government-commissioned biogas plants to install tamper-proof smart energy meters and continuous monitoring systems within one month. Live data on water quality and discharge must be uploaded to CPCB and State Pollution Control Board websites.
The CPCB will conduct quarterly unannounced inspections of major treatment plants. Senior nodal officers must also be appointed within two weeks and submit monthly progress reports to the Supreme Court.